Bokeh (but not really)

So, I tried to do Bokeh I even cut out some construction paper, but it was just not working. I changed everything as best as I could, but I still couldn’t get every light as a circle some of them did work but post of it did not. 

My ISO was 1600 and my f-sop was at 3.5/4.5

I just used some white printer paper and cut a circle into it.

My thoughts about this is it would have been a very good picture if I had figured out how to set all the settings, I wanted it to be at.